Have you ever missed someone deeply, even though you never officially dated them? That strange ache in your chest when their name pops up on your screen. The way memories creep into your mind at 2 AM, especially after a drink or two. If you’re 19, heartbroken, and still thinking about that one girl who made you feel alive, you’re not alone. This is a true love story—not about a relationship that happened, but about one that almost did. It’s raw, real, and human.
Chapter 1: Two Strangers in a New World
We met as college freshmen in Florida, both far from home but only an hour apart back in the Northeast—me from Connecticut, her from New York. That small connection felt huge in a place where everything else was unfamiliar. We had an inside joke where I’d tease her about being from New York. I dragged the joke on too long, but somehow, she kept laughing.
I hadn’t dated anyone seriously since middle school, so I came to college with hope. Hope that I’d finally experience real love. When I met her, something felt different. She saw me. Not as someone to make fun of, or ignore, but someone to invite in.
Chapter 2: The Friend Zone That Felt Like More
She liked having me around. She invited me to events. She laughed at my jokes, even when she called them dumb. She made me feel funny and appreciated. Her smile—she always put it down, but I thought it was beautiful. I never told her how much I loved it.
I didn’t realise it at first, but she only saw me as a friend. And honestly? That hurt. But at the same time, she chose me to be her friend. She included me, made space for me in her life. And in a time when I felt invisible, that meant everything.
That’s when I fell for her. Not because she was pretty (though she is), but because she was kind, real, and genuinely cared.
Chapter 3: The Breaking Point
When she finally told me she didn’t want anything romantic, I tried to be okay with it. I told myself it was fine. But it wasn’t. Deep down, it broke me.
She liked my company, but still didn’t want me that way. That truth hit me harder than anything. And instead of accepting it with grace, I spiralled.
I became cold. Angry. I started texting her passive-aggressive messages. I assumed the worst. If she was busy, I thought it meant she didn’t care. I’d lash out, then regret it, then do it all over again. I was drowning emotionally, and I dragged her into the storm.
Chapter 4: The Mental Spiral
One week, I hit a low point. I was researching how to end it all. I tried to act normal while hanging out with the friend group. Took some pills thinking I’d hide the trip. I didn’t. They noticed. I got removed from the club and the group.
No one asked if I was okay. Not the leader of the group. Not the others. It felt like they were more embarrassed than concerned. The same leader who had warned me about her, made unfair judgments about her past, didn’t even try to understand me when I needed help.
Except her.
She was mad at me. Rightfully. But I think she was the one who called the school to check on me. Even after all I’d put her through. That still sits with me. She cared when no one else did.
Chapter 5: When Things Could’ve Gotten Better…
The next semester, I thought it was over. Then she started being friendly again. Not flirty. Just kind. She responded to texts. She treated me like a human. That threw me off because the others never did.
I thought maybe we could be friends again. Then I messed up. Again.
She didn’t respond to a meme or a message. I got nervous. Overthought everything. So I drunk texted her. Something dumb. Something like, “Did I do a good job back when I liked you?” I was trying to ask if I was ever appreciated—but it came out all wrong. She didn’t reply. And I don’t blame her.
Chapter 6: Still Missing Her
I asked her later if she wanted to be included in my Instagram year-end post. She said yes, that she appreciated me asking. That meant something. But I know she wouldn’t put me in hers. Not because she’s cruel—just because we’re not close anymore.
She once told me she didn’t want to be “in-person friends.” She didn’t want to hang out anymore. I get it. But it hurts. I wish I could text her now, tonight, as I write this. But she deserves more than a drunk text. So I’m writing this here. Maybe she’ll see it. Maybe she won’t.
Chapter 7: Why Do I Miss Her So Much?
I never dated her. We didn’t kiss. We didn’t even have a “thing.” But I miss her. I miss her because she made me feel seen. Because when I was at my lowest, she showed up. Because she laughed at my jokes when I felt like I wasn’t funny. Because I hurt her and she still cared.
I miss the version of myself that I was around her—the one who felt normal. Like I had a shot at being in love. Like I could be enough.
Chapter 8: So, How Do I Move Forward?
Here’s what I’ve learned—and maybe it’ll help you, too:
-
Missing someone doesn’t require a relationship. Connection happens in many forms. Love can happen even when it’s not mutual.
-
Feelings aren’t wrong. But our actions still matter. I let pain become anger and I lost a good person. That part was on me.
-
She cared. That still matters. Even if we never speak again, I know someone once cared enough to check if I was okay.
-
It’s not the end. Just because it didn’t work with her doesn’t mean it won’t with someone else.
-
Healing takes time. And you have to want to heal.
I’m learning now that I have to forgive myself. I hurt someone. I let my emotions take control. But I can grow from it. I can choose to become someone better—not for her, but for myself.
Final Thoughts: A Message to Her (If She Ever Reads This)
I don’t expect anything. I don’t need you to respond. But I hope you know that you meant something real to me. I’m sorry for the pain I caused. And I hope you’re doing okay. You’re kind, funny, and stronger than you know.
FAQs
Can you miss someone you never dated?
Yes, it’s completely normal to miss someone you never dated, especially if you shared a deep emotional connection or unspoken feelings. Emotional bonds don’t always require a romantic relationship.
Why do I feel heartbroken over a girl I was never with?
You may feel heartbroken because you imagined the possibility of a relationship, and the emotional investment felt real. Unfulfilled expectations can hurt just as much as a breakup.
How do I stop thinking about a girl I never dated?
Try focusing on self-growth, spending time with friends, setting new goals, and limiting emotional triggers like old messages or photos. Journaling or therapy can also help process your feelings.
Is it love if we never dated but I still miss her?
It could be love or emotional attachment. You may have connected with her personality, kindness, or the way she made you feel, even if the feelings weren’t mutual or romantic.
Can unspoken feelings hurt more than a breakup?
Yes, unspoken or one-sided emotions can be painful because they create “what if” scenarios that the mind keeps revisiting. Closure is harder without clear communication or an ending.
Should I reach out to her even if it’s been a long time?
Only if your intentions are respectful and you’re ready for any outcome. Reaching out with clarity and care—not while drunk or emotional—shows maturity and respect for her boundaries.
Why do I feel guilty for missing her?
Guilt can stem from past mistakes, like emotional outbursts or how things ended. It’s okay to miss someone while also acknowledging areas where you could’ve acted differently.
Can a short connection have a lasting emotional impact?
Yes. Sometimes brief interactions leave a strong impact, especially during vulnerable periods in life. It’s the quality of connection, not the duration, that stays with us.
How do I forgive myself for how I treated her?
Start by acknowledging your mistakes, learning from them, and becoming a better person moving forward. Self-forgiveness takes time but begins with personal growth and honest reflection.
Will I ever find someone who understands me like she did?
Yes. While it may not feel like it now, time, healing, and growth will help you meet someone who values you and shares your emotional depth. Trust the journey—you’re not alone.
